Are Short Term Rentals in Treasure Island Florida Worth It?

by Hunt Brothers Realty

A Real Estate Investment Guide

Treasure Island Florida has become one of the most sought after destinations on the Gulf Coast for vacationers and real estate investors alike. With its wide sandy beaches, walkable downtown, waterfront dining, and close proximity to St Pete Beach and Madeira Beach, this laid back coastal city offers a strong opportunity for those considering short term rental investments.

As demand for vacation homes and income producing properties continues to rise, buyers are asking an important question. Are short term rentals in Treasure Island truly worth it as an investment? Here is a guide to the benefits, considerations, and the local market factors you need to know before purchasing a short term rental property in Treasure Island.

Why Real Estate Investors Focus on Treasure Island

Treasure Island sits at the center of one of Florida’s busiest vacation corridors. Tourists flock here all year round because of the beaches, boutique shopping, casual beach bars, live entertainment, and easy access to Tampa Bay. This steady demand means well positioned vacation rentals have the potential to deliver strong occupancy rates and rental income.

Short term rentals through platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo experience the highest occupancy from December through April and during the summer months. Well managed properties in the right location can generate significant income, often outperforming long term rentals.

Benefits of Owning a Short Term Rental in Treasure Island

High Rental Demand
Beachfront and near beach properties with Gulf views and resort style amenities such as a pool or deck consistently book well. These properties see peak occupancy during holidays, spring break, and seasonal high demand periods.

Personal Use Flexibility
Unlike long term rental properties, short term rentals allow owners to block off time for their own vacations and still earn income the rest of the year. This offers a combination of lifestyle and financial benefits.

Strong Property Appreciation
Treasure Island’s coastal location and limited supply of land have historically supported strong property value growth. Along with cash flow, investors often see long term equity appreciation.

Supportive Tourism Market
The local economy depends on tourism and Pinellas County continues to invest in infrastructure, beach improvements, and events that attract both new and repeat visitors.

Key Considerations Before You Buy

Local Regulations and Permits
Treasure Island does allow short term rentals in certain zones, but the rules vary by neighborhood and property type. You will need to comply with minimum stay requirements, apply for a business tax receipt, and meet safety standards. Always confirm zoning and regulations before you purchase.

Management Demands
Short term rentals require more attention than traditional rentals. Daily management involves booking, guest communication, cleaning, and repairs. Many investors hire a vacation rental management company to handle these tasks.

Seasonal Market Fluctuations
Although demand is strong overall, bookings are seasonal. Slower months occur during late summer and fall. It is important to budget conservatively and plan for off season.

Insurance and Maintenance
Properties located close to the Gulf may require flood or wind insurance. Salt air and humidity mean regular maintenance is essential to keep the property in top condition.

What Types of Properties Perform Best

The most successful short term rentals in Treasure Island typically include:

Beachfront condos and cottages
Homes with pools, hot tubs, or large outdoor decks
Units within easy walking distance to restaurants and shops
Pet friendly rentals
Multi unit properties that allow flexibility for owners and guests

Is Investing in Treasure Island Worth It?

For investors looking for strong vacation rental income, long term property value growth, and the flexibility to enjoy their own property, Treasure Island presents a compelling opportunity. With careful property selection, compliance with local regulations, and effective management, short term rentals in Treasure Island can provide a rewarding combination of lifestyle and financial return.

Thinking About Buying a Vacation Rental in Treasure Island?

Whether you are looking for a turnkey short term rental ready to list or a fixer upper with potential, our team at Hunt Brothers Realty specializes in helping investors navigate this dynamic coastal market. We assist with everything from understanding local regulations to identifying high performing properties across Treasure Island, Anna Maria Island, Holmes Beach, Bradenton, and beyond.

We provide: